State Comptroller Audit Critical Of Five Upstate Industrial Development Agencies


The New York State Comptroller’s office recently released audits on 5 upstate Industrial Development Agencies. According to NYS Comptroller Tom DiNapoli:

Too many communities are left with unanswered questions about the effectiveness of providing costly tax breaks to private companies. IDAs owe it to taxpayers to appropriately track whether companies are delivering on their promises and take back benefits if they are not.

The one Central New York IDA that was audited was the Oswego County IDA. The Comptroller’s audit found that the County of Oswego IDA:

•Established an unauthorized revolving loan program, using its own funds, to finance a portion of the cost of projects. The IDA had 90 loans outstanding as of May 31, 2014, totaling nearly $9.6 million that were financed by its own funds.
•There is no formal process to compare current and projected jobs at the time of application to the reported number of jobs actually created and retained.
•Auditors found 31 companies that received loans only created half of the jobs they said they would create.

Preparing A Diverse Workforce


By 2044, people of color will account for a majority of the U.S. population. In an essay for the Brookings Institute, Jennifer Bradley examines efforts in U.S. metropolitan areas to prepare a more diverse workforce. Bradley showcases efforts of organizations in Minneapolis-Saint Paul to close persistent education and employment gaps facing its rapidly growing population. As Europe and countries like Japan face a declining working-age demographic, population growth among people of color has the potential to give the U.S. a competitive advantage in the 21st century economy.

Department of Transportation Supports Local/Targeted Hiring . . . For A Year

fairshot Check the links to two interesting articles on the Department of Transportation (DOT) pilot project “Local Hire.” The program allows localities to institute hiring requirements, such as requiring developers of transit projects to hire people from within designated low-income zip codes–but only for the next 12 months.

This pilot project actually defers a DOT regulation of 40 years standing forbidding localities from placing requirements on hiring. Hopefully, the one year pilot project will be renewed and become the new default policy. “Local Hire” or an equivalent will be crucial to ensuring that jobs are created for our community when the Rt. 81 project becomes a reality.

OCIDA Tax Deal for Proposed Destiny Hotel Tied To CBA?


Check out the very interesting article on the continuing saga of Destiny USA developer Robert Congel’s attempts to build a hotel near the oil city shopping mall.

The Onondaga County Legislature chairman Ryan McMahon placed two conditions on any tax deal for the proposed 225 room, $75 million project: 1) a Destiny-funded study on the economic feasibility of another hotel in the area 2) a community benefits agreement that would create a cash fund to benefit the city.

While Destiny did pony up cash for the feasibility study and was apparently negotiating with McMahon and the Onondaga County Industrial Development Agency, apparently the hotel project is no longer being pursued. This latest decision to not pursue the hotel could be another ploy by the Destiny folks. Heaven knows they have mastered the art of delay in their decades-long campaign to seek public benefits for private profit.

This whole scenario begs an interesting question: is the best way to blunt a Congel/Destiny demand for more corporate welfare a straightforward counter-demand for a CBA?

Public Subsidies For Financing Construction Of New Stadiums For Pro Sports Teams Under Fire

President Obama’s new budget proposes eliminating the ability of cities to use bond issues to help private pro sports franchises finance the construction of new stadiums and arenas.

Interesting that the article notes that this may become a wedge issue inside the Republican party. Traditional GOP’ers that work to help funnel money to business interests are facing opposition from Tea Party Republicans that oppose most forms of government spending.

The sports website Deadspin wonders if Community Benefit Agreements (CBA’s) may be another way to stop pro sports teams from extorting public benefits from cash-strapped cities. The genesis of this article is the struggle over a mandatory CBA ordinance in Detroit. The ordinance has been proposed by a Detroit city councilor disgusted by a city dealing with bankruptcy financing $285 million (over half of the $450 million price tag) for a new arena for the Red Wings hockey team. The Wings owner Mike Ilitch’s net worth is estimated at over $3 billion.

Detroit’s City Council has proposed an ordinance that would require a developer to negotiate a CBA on any project receiving more than $300,000 in tax benefits. The Mayor is opposed, the chamber of commerce is opposed and the state legislature tried to pass legislation to outlaw all cities in the state from passing such ordinances.

But many folks in Detroit are still pushing–especially those living and working in low income neighborhoods whose tax dollars subsidize millionaire and billionaire developers. Check out the site of the Equitable Detroit Coalition and their fight for the Detroit CBA ordinance.

San Diego’s Plans For Economic Development Incorporate Community Benefit Agreements

The city of San Diego (CA) runs its own non-profit agency (Civic San Diego) that facilitates deals with developers for specific low income neighborhoods.

Check out this in-depth article from a local alternative newspaper urging the agency to go beyond just planning for the physical buildings in the neighborhoods and starting its plans by assessing the most acute needs of the community’s residents.

The non-profit has also created an online site to allow residents to “to share their interests, collaborate to evolve ideas, and identify and prioritize shared values for their neighborhoods.” The idea is to create consensus on desired community benefits.

Detroit Likely To Debate City CBA Ordinance

The City Council of Detroit (MI) is likely to introduce a proposed ordinance requiring private entities that either receive tax credits or buy a city-owned vacant building to negotiate a community benefits agreement (CBA). The CBA’s would only be required if the value of the tax credits or building purchase exceeds $300,000.

The proposal is opposed by Detroit’s mayor Mike Duggan and the city’s Chamber of Commerce. The plan has the support of the Council President and many business organizations located in low income neighborhoods.

At the end of 2013, the state of Michigan threatened to pass legislation that would prohibit CBA’s in any municipality in the state–but no action was taken on the bill. Ironically, Detroit Mayor Duggan opposed the state bill, fearing it would create precedent for the state to limit the autonomy of local governments.

I guess he prefers to kill CBA’s locally! Stay Tuned!!

Want to Create Jobs In Your Community? ORGANIZE!

An interesting report has just been issued by the Gamaliel organizing network, a coalition of faith-based community organizing groups throughout the country. Entitled “Jobs And More Jobs–The Economic Impact of Community Organizing” the report details the public and private sector jobs that were created through campaigns around issues such as food deserts, equal access to public transit transportation and better educational opportunities.

This report fills in some of the human details of the report that Gamaliel issued in 2012 that quantified the economic impact of their organizing: an estimated $17.2 Billion in GDP created in the past two years by the new workers.

The community organizing also showcases the use of community benefit agreements and the hiring of ex-offenders returning to our communities–models we hope to expand throughout our communities, state and country.

Bill to Reform IDA’s Will Be Re-Introduced (And It Is Still Needed!)



Western NY Assemblyman Sean Ryan intends to re-introduce the JOBS Act–a bill that would make the actions of the state’s Industrial Development Agencies (IDA’s) more transparent.

“IDA members are not elected by anybody, but they give away millions of taxpayer dollars,” Ryan said. “Under the JOBS Act, the IDA members who approve a project must then submit it for approval to elected officials like the town council. And when there’s public scrutiny, big massive projects tend to go away.”

This interesting article from City and State details some of the concerns of folks from Western NY with the Erie County IDA and how it lavishes tax breaks on corporations that could fund their own projects and do not contribute to the public good.

In Syracuse, we see the same problems–the most recent is an exemption from mortgage recording taxes for new hotels being developed in the Inner Harbor. That decision by the Syracuse Industrial Development Agency (SIDA) means the region’s public transportation system, which is partially funded by that tax, will receive nothing. Millions for rich corporations–nothing for a transit system looking at fare increases and route cuts. I guess we know whose side SIDA is on.

Cleveland Officials To Discuss Their Public/Private Partnership To Create Jobs

BuildingEquity Flyer final pg 1

On Friday, October 24 at Toomey Abbott Towers from 9:30 – 11:30 am, the Urban Jobs Task Force and CenterState CEO, with funding from the Gifford Foundation,  will be hosting “Building Equity.”  Natoya Walker Minor, the Chief of Public Affairs for the city of Cleveland and Brian Hall, the Director of Inclusion of the Greater Cleveland Partnership, will present “How to Connect Growth and Opportunity.”  Through their respective positions, they are building social and employment equity in Cleveland.  In partnership with Cleveland’s employers, developers, educational institutions and unions they are creating a Culture of Inclusion.  Natoya and Brian will share with us the lessons learned and strategies used on this journey towards a more equitable Cleveland.  “Building Equity” is free and open to the public.  There is limited seating so reservations are recommended.  Contact Ms. Liso Smith at 315-416-6363 or

BuildingEquity Flyer Final pg 2